An analysis of the controversy over the electoral college

Masachusetts also used popular vote, choosing 17 electors by congressional district and 2 at-large. Nevada was one of several states which insisted on electronic voting systems that create a paper trail.

Of course, for the Framers, the issue was now what if- as they considered to be the more likely happening- no one commanded a majority of this "Electoral Vote"? Only a combination of dumb luck the 4 lucky breaks noted abovepolitical skill and last-minute compromise prevented Aaron Burr from being elected President or a constitutional crisis from ensuing come 4 March It will take a huge outcry to make a Constitutional amendment to change the Electoral College viable.

In any case, eliminating the Electoral College would not be an easy process. This mythology is further bolstered by a tendency to view the Constitutional Convention as having been well above the fray of ordinary Politics: Do we now have established political parties to prevent pluralities?

However, look at the other effects of a small number of entrenched parties: Forthe new State of Indiana used choice by its legislature and Massachusetts- seemingly having trouble settling on a permanent system- once more returned to legislative choice while New Jersey and North Carolina returned that year to popular vote both "General Ticket" statewide popular vote.

The plan here was for the Electors collectively to put forth a number of candidates for President from different parts of the country: Once the Convention had decided on a single executive back in June, its delegates pretty much knew or at least came to know soon enough who that executive was likely to be at first: Meanwhile, some opponents of the Electoral College even say that the small states are grossly overrepresented in Congress in the first place, and by giving them this extra power, the Electoral College is in actuality distorting the balance of power between the states and tipping the balance in the favor of the small states.

Finally, the Electoral College is not a popular institution. The Presidential Electors would now cast their votes in their respective States on the first Monday after the second Wednesday in December- this provision is still in force and, thus, the Electors will vote for President and Vice-President this year on Monday 18 December ; Congress would meet to open, announce, count and tabulate the Electoral Vote on 6 January unless that day be a Sunday, whereupon they are to meet on 7 January.

Aaron Burr was appointed as Vice President.

An analysis of the controversy over the electoral college

International affairs columnist Renard Sexton began the series with an analysis of polling leading up to the election; [ 23] then posts by Silver, Andrew Gelman and Sexton analyzed the reported returns and political implications. There have been such faithless electors over the years, starting way back inwhen a Pennsylvania elector changed his vote from John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, for reasons that remain unclear.

The polls-only model relied only on polls from a particular state, while the polls-plus model was based on state polls, national polls and endorsements. The Magazine for Students of Statistics. For each contest, FiveThirtyEight produced probability distributions and average expected vote shares per both of these models.

Thus, on 21 Decemberanticipating these difficulties, the Senate appointed a committee per an earlier Resolution of that body to meet with a House committee appointed the next day per an even earlier Resolution to discuss how best to handle what was a rather dicey situation, considering the Nation had only lately readmitted three of the four disputed States which had been members of the Confederate States of America that had been the cause of the Civil War and the subsequent Reconstruction then still ongoing in the South.

Thus, this evidence is actually the fault of the people who are following certain voting patterns, not the fault of the inanimate Electoral College. Each of these models relied initially on a combination of electoral history, demographics, and polling. These were most noticeable in those colonies which were affected by the Proclamation Lines of and with which the young British Empire attempted to keep the frontier of settlement from encroaching upon Indian lands in the Ohio Valley - New York, Pennsylvania, Virginia, North Carolina and Georgia- but they were visible in other colonies as well; New Jersey- totally untouched by the Proclamation Lines- had "factionalism" exacerbated by its really being the forced union of two earlier colonies with quite different traditions of local government: Florida, Louisiana, Oregon and South Carolina.

The next day, the two houses of Congress chose their allotted "Commissioners"- the House choosing 3 Democrats and 2 Republicans one of whom was a future President- Congressman James A.

But if you see something that doesn't look right, contact us! There is a complicated system, laid out in the Constitution, called the Electoral College which is not a place or a school.

This model, too, relied in part on demographic information but mainly involved a complex method of aggregating polling results. In six of the 24 existing states, the Electoral College members were appointed by the State Legislature.

Access Denied

Madison had prudently waited for Tennessee before issuing his decree and the new Electoral Vote casting system was in place for the Election after all!

Since serious candidates must join entrenched parties to win electors, more extreme candidates cannot win a nomination.

2004 United States election voting controversies

Minorities can band together and form a coalition that wields a huge amount of political power.The Electoral College prevents pluralities (no candidate getting a full 50% of the vote) by requiring half-plus-one of the electoral votes for anyone to be elected president. University of the Pacific - Electoral College Reform 6/21/12 AM the Electoral College has been a subject riddled with controversy.

Of the thousands states have a greater influence over the apportionment of their. The Electoral College has been an issue of great debate for a long period of time. Recently the governor of Illinois signed into effect a bill that would give the state's electoral votes to the winner of the nation-wide popular election.

An analysis of the controversy over the electoral college Ratified June 21, The Shame of College Sports. Contrary to modern an analysis of the controversy over the electoral college a comparison of buddhism and christianity in views of afterlife perceptions, the An analysis of bob fosses satirical film cabaret founding generation did not intend An analysis of benjamin franklin as a.

Controversial Elections. All 73 Democratic-Republican members of the Electoral College voted faithfully, casting two votes each, one for Jefferson and one for Burr. This election was clearly corrupted and has found a place in every debate over the Electoral College since.

For a more complete analysis and timeline of the election. FiveThirtyEight, sometimes referred to asis a website that focuses on opinion poll analysis, politics, economics, and sports blogging.

Debate over the Electoral College revived again

The website, which takes its name from the number of electors in the United States electoral college, was founded on March 7,as a polling aggregation website with a blog created by analyst Nate .

An analysis of the controversy over the electoral college
Rated 5/5 based on 45 review